Legendary stories of survival

Young people in warm coats and hats queue patiently around the corner to buy a frozen yoghurt from Yo-Chi, the new Australian viral sensation, which recently opened up next to our office in Notting Hill.

Queues for the latest experiential hype are normal. Hyrox is as hard to get tickets for as Glastonbury. A recent one was rather more unexpected. Nearly 300,000 people joined the queue for Bayeux Tapestry tickets, with Piper team members’ British Museum memberships suddenly a sought-after commodity.

The popularity is unsurprising for something that has survived for almost 1,000 years. It is both a teller of legends and a legend in its own right. Generation after generation, the tapestry has been preserved by its community – from the monks who first commissioned it, to the French Resistance who saved it – because it holds significant meaning.

At Piper, we see brands as capable of serving the same purpose as legends. They are living collections of stories and beliefs that adapt to the times and are owned by their customers, creating community, values and a sense of identity. Like legends, the best brands are experts at communicating their message, implanting it in rituals, language, buildings and more, so that their community can give it meaning and pass it on.

We call these brand legends. They are the ultimate survivors, outlasting their original storytellers because they created something so special and important that it was worth keeping, just like the Bayeux Tapestry.

A hero’s memory

All legends have a hero. Brand legends have captivating founder stories and values that are remembered and passed on, guiding the brand through the perils of its epic journey. The best brands can survive their founders and flourish without them. Ensuring this is a brand’s ultimate test and measure of success.

Founders do this by nurturing a strong cultural memory, the beliefs and behaviours that define the brand’s identity. Taken well beyond marketing, it is found in the employee handbook, hiring processes, financial updates and annual team parties.

Once embedded, this cultural memory is carried instinctively by the organisation, making it hard for future leaders and owners to corrupt or unravel. In the Tapestry, the hero’s story is woven into fabric and made unforgettable.

It is are also something to come back to in times of uncertainty. M&S and Rolls-Royce CEOs have both led recent turnarounds by returning to what made the brands special at the very beginning.

Enshrined in rituals and artefacts

The Tapestry isn’t technically a tapestry at all but an embroidery, almost 70 metres of wool yarn stitched onto linen, most likely by skilled English embroiderers, many of them women. It was made well enough to last, and its value was enshrined in ritual. For centuries it was kept at Bayeux Cathedral and hung out every year for the week of the Feast of St John the Baptist.

Brand legends protect the value of their products by building quality into a ritual people experience again and again. Guinness does it through its great quality product, its ritualistic serve and by encouraging drinkers to play the game of splitting the G.

Culturally relevant

Like all great legends, the Tapestry can have its meaning flexed. In 1803, Napoleon had it displayed at the Louvre as propaganda to inspire his troops ahead of a planned invasion of Britain, casting himself as the next William the Conqueror. More recently, British newspapers printed satirical cartoons titled the “Bye-EU Tapestry” to mock the UK’s departure from the EU. Fittingly for an object about conflict between the two nations, it has also become a symbol of Anglo-French friendship, most visibly in its loan to the British Museum, its first time in the UK in nearly 1,000 years.

Legends survive by staying culturally relevant across generations. For brands, this means being at the forefront of consumer trends, collaborating with brands and influencers that share their values, and telling their story through a visual handwriting and tone of voice that feel current. Greggs’ collaboration with Primark, from flip-flops to swimming costumes, sold out, while Paul Smith continues to define Britishness through collaborations with Mini and Land Rover. His most recent capsule collection highlights UK makers, from wool in Dundee to yarn in Nottingham.

Community owned

In August 1944, days before the liberation of Paris, Himmler sent an urgent coded message urging that the Tapestry, then held in the Louvre, be taken to “a place of safety”. The story goes that British codebreakers intercepted the order and shared it with the French Resistance, who hid the Tapestry in the Louvre’s basement, out of the Nazis’ reach. The legend has become one of survival, with the Tapestry saved by a community who felt a sense of duty and ownership.

Brand legends are owned and protected by their communities. Fans nurture the brand and feel part of its story, adopting it to fit their identity. They also protect the brand when things go wrong and are the first to push for change or point out poorly thought-through communication or products.

When Cadbury discontinued Wispa in 2003, reworking it as Dairy Milk Bubbly, fans set up online petitions and even stormed the stage at Glastonbury in 2007 with a “Bring Back Wispa” banner. Cadbury brought the bar back that October, saying consumer passion had swayed its decision, and made the return permanent in 2008.

Embedding and passing on cultural memory

At Piper, we are constantly trying to understand why and how the best brands survive, which is why we talk about brand legends. Neither size nor longevity alone makes a brand legend. What distinguishes them is that they have done both, together, while remaining genuinely loved.

Scale and financial muscle do not guarantee survival. Of the 100 businesses in the FTSE 100 when it launched in 1984, around the time Piper was founded, fewer than 30 remain. The rest have been acquired, broken up, dropped out of the index or, in three cases, gone out of business.

Our role as investors is to help embed that cultural memory deep into the business model so the brand can survive. It means growing at the right pace, saying no to short-term growth at the expense of the brand and its culture, and investing in things that may only pay off in years to come. We help founders navigate succession by passing the cultural memory on to the next generation of leadership.

We cannot be responsible for the actions of future owners of our partner brands, but we have learnt to build, in our time with them, a cultural immune system that guards against that risk. This is how we contribute to their long-lasting legacy.

Legends take a long time to build. We can only dream of our partner brands being around in 1,000 years like the Tapestry, especially as the world changes faster than ever. At the very least, we hope they too can inspire queues for generations after their founding. Yo-Chi might be a household brand legend by then.

​